A report released just last week shows just what American shoplifters are putting in their bags, their pockets, and anywhere they can conceal their loot. On top of the list are beauty and cosmetic products. In this article from MSNBC there are several theories of why these items rank so high, but I’m not entirely convinced they’re right.
According to the Food Marketing Institute, cosmetics account for 20% of all goods stolen from supermarkets in 2008.
s
Sure they’re right when they assume that stealing an eyeliner pencil is easier than stealing a package of steaks, but is there really some underlying psychological reason why beauty products are more attractive to shoplifters?
One psychiatrist interviewed for the story believes it has little to do with the actual objects and more to do with rebellion and self destructive behavior. He says “I think if you’re stealing stuff, then probably you aren’t happy and you may feel it’s about the way you look.”
They also state that these products are likely hot because they are often being taken by teens, as sort of a rite of passage. This acting out is sort of a modest walk on the wild side. A little bit of a risk for a little bit of a pay off.
Finally, they suggest maybe stealing products like pregnancy tests, hair color, and weight loss medications is a way of hiding them, of not admitting to having to need such potentially embarrassing products. Sure, buying hemorrhoid cream is embarrassing, but that isn’t on the list at all.
What isn’t discussed is the possibility that these tiny products often cost way more than other supermarket items of similar size, though they are often considered “necessities” by the women who use them. If you’ve got a $25 budget at the store and have to buy moisturizer and groceries, dropping the $15 moisturizer in your purse is a little more alluring and likely not about your self esteem or your rebellious nature at all.
Now, ask any woman (or man) if their shoplifting behavior was worth getting caught for and you can likely guess their answer—of course not. But they believe the risk is so low that they will take it if it means being able to purchase more of the things they need.
There is no excuse for stealing—no moral excuse and really no legal excuse either. If you’ve been caught shoplifting, the judge isn’t going to care if you have body image issues and were too embarrassed to buy your cellulite cream.
But, if you don’t have a lengthy criminal record and you have the desire to make things right, your defense attorney may be able to work out a favorable plea agreement with the prosecution. You may even get off with just serving some community service or paying a fine.
The way your case turns out depends on the state in which you face charges and the specifics of the crime itself. If you’re facing shoplifting charges contact us to speak with a local defense attorney that can help.
About David Matson